Plea Bargaining in Orange County Criminal Cases

Plea bargaining involves negotiations between you (and your lawyer) and the prosecutor to resolve a case without going to trial.

In this article, we’ll discuss plea bargaining, its types, advantages, disadvantages, and how it works.

Let’s dive in!

Plea bargaining happens when you agree to plead guilty to a lesser charge or one of several charges in exchange for concessions from the prosecutor. These concessions can include reduced charges, lighter sentences, or the dismissal of other charges.

The main goal is to settle the case quickly, avoid the uncertainties of a trial, and find a solution both sides can accept.

There are three main types of plea bargains:

1. Charge Bargaining: You plead guilty to a less serious charge than the original one. For example, instead of facing felony theft charges, you might plead guilty to misdemeanor theft.
2. Sentence Bargaining: You plead guilty to the original charge but get a lighter sentence. This could mean getting probation instead of jail time.
3. Fact Bargaining: You agree to admit to certain facts in exchange for the prosecutor not presenting other facts that could be more damaging. This type is less common but can still be helpful.

Each type of plea bargain can benefit you depending on the case and the outcome you and your lawyer want to achieve.

The benefits of plea bargaining include the following:

1. Reduced sentences: You often get lighter penalties than if you were found guilty at trial.
2. Certainty and control: Plea bargains provide a known outcome, avoiding the unpredictability of a trial.
3. Faster resolution: Cases are resolved more quickly, allowing you to move on with your life.
4. Reduced costs: Both sides save money on the costs associated with a trial, including legal fees and court expenses.
5. Lesser charges: You might end up with less severe charges, which can have fewer long-term consequences.
6. Judicial efficiency: Plea bargaining helps reduce the burden on courts by resolving cases without the need for a trial, allowing the judicial system to run more smoothly.

Despite its benefits, plea bargaining also has some downsides:

1. You might feel pressured to plead guilty to avoid the risk of a harsher sentence at trial, even if you are innocent.
2. Accepting a plea deal usually means giving up the right to appeal the conviction or sentence.
3. Plea bargains can be seen as letting you off too easily, which might not always feel like justice to victims or the community.
4. Victims and their families might feel that justice isn’t fully served, especially if you get a much lighter sentence.
5. You might feel forced into accepting a plea deal due to fear of a worse outcome at trial, especially if you lack strong legal representation.

Here’s how plea bargaining usually works:

The process starts with talks between your defense attorney and the prosecutor. Your defense might suggest these discussions if they think a plea deal could benefit you.

The prosecutor might make an offer, which your defense can accept, reject, or counter. There can be several rounds of negotiation.

Your defense attorney reviews the offer, considering how strong the prosecution’s case is, the potential sentence if convicted at trial, and whether you are willing to accept the terms.

Your defense attorney talks about the offer with you, explaining the potential outcomes, risks, and benefits. You must decide if you want to accept the plea deal.

If both parties agree, the plea bargain is put in writing. It details the charges you will plead guilty to and what the prosecutor has agreed to do in return.

The judge reviews the plea agreement to make sure it’s fair and that you understand what you’re agreeing to. If the judge approves, you formally enter the plea in court, and the agreed-upon sentence is given.

If you find yourself in trouble with the criminal justice system in Orange County and want to plea bargain, get the help of an experienced criminal defense attorney.